Home » Uncategorized » Let them have vouchers! And a Caveat of Significance.

Let them have vouchers! And a Caveat of Significance.

I suggested in a post yesterday in response to a National Education Association message calling for people to fight the push for vouchers that instead of fighting against them, the argument be that all schools, so they can be properly competitive be afforded the same amount of per pupil expenditure as the recognized to be best private schools in the nation.  My point is this, that all students deserve to have the opportunity to receive the best education they can possibly get and, with vouchers, the amount usually offered precludes most from going to the kind of private schools that parents who can afford tuition like to send their children.  Since, even if all could afford the “best” schools only a small minority would be able to because there would not be room.  The answer, then, is to bring all schools up to a level of excellence and it does seem that excellence comes at a cost.  Money, of course, is not the only factor that accounts for school excellence, but it is one important one if only classroom size is taken into account, the factor that determines how much interpersonal interaction will take place between educator and student, a proven necessity for instruction that promotes growth of independent critical thinking, something I understand to be one of, perhaps the most, important goals of truly good school programs.  Let the people have their vouchers but make certain that before such a step is taken that all students have the choice of going to an excellent school.  Until then, good numbers, most, despite their having vouchers, are not guaranteed that a good choice exists for them.

Ten Highly Rated Private Schools

Phillips Academy: $40,000 per year

Phillips Exeter: $37,125 per year

Harvard-Westlake School: $35,900 per year

St. Paul’s school: $55,000 per year

Horace Mann: $46,000 per year

The College Preparatory School: $40,310 per year

The Harker School: $45,877 per year

Lakeside School: $32,000 per year

Stanford Online School: $19,500 per year

Trinity School: $47,965 per year

Average = $32,696 (and note that an online school is included at bargain price!)

The average per pupil expenditure in public schools in the United States according to U.S. Census Bureau: $10,700 (skewed by states such as New York where average per pupil expenditure is $19,818.  Note that these are 2015 figures—The range is the $19,818 spent in New York to $6,555 in Utah.

 

Comments are invited

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s